Basic Concepts: State, Power and Legitimacy
Government · WAEC and JAMB · SS2 and SS3
Every other topic in Government rests on these definitions, and the examiner marks them strictly: a candidate who confuses a state with a nation or power with authority loses marks right through the paper. Section A objectives test the distinctions, and essay questions ask you to define a concept and then apply it.
What you need to know
- A state has four essential attributes: a defined territory, a permanent population, a government, and sovereignty. Remove any one and what remains is not a state. A refugee camp has people but no territory of its own; a colony has territory, population and a government but no sovereignty.
- A nation is a group of people bound by common ancestry, language, culture, history or shared sentiment. Nigeria is one state containing many nations: Yoruba, Igbo, Hausa, Fulani, Tiv, Ijaw, Kanuri and hundreds more. A nation-state is the rare case where the two coincide fairly closely, as in Japan or Somalia.
- Government means three different things depending on context: the institution that makes and enforces rules, the group of people currently holding office, and the process of governing itself. In an exam answer, say which sense you are using.
- Sovereignty is supreme, final and absolute authority within a territory, subject to no higher power internally or externally. Internal sovereignty is supremacy over all persons and associations inside the state; external sovereignty is independence from the control of any other state.
- Sovereignty is in theory absolute, indivisible, permanent and inalienable, but in practice it is limited by international treaties, membership of bodies such as ECOWAS and the UN, international public opinion, the constitution itself, and the economic pressure of lenders and trading partners.
- Locations of sovereignty are distinguished in exam answers: legal sovereignty lies with the body legally empowered to make binding law, political sovereignty lies with the electorate who can remove that body, and popular sovereignty is the doctrine that ultimate power belongs to the people.
- Power is the ability to influence or control the behaviour of others, with or without their consent, and it can rest on force, wealth, knowledge, numbers or office. An armed robber has power over his victim.
- Authority is the right to exercise power, recognised and accepted by those over whom it is exercised. A policeman and an armed robber may both have the power to stop your car; only the policeman has the authority. Authority is power clothed in right.
- Max Weber classified authority into three types: traditional authority resting on long-accepted custom, as with an Oba or Emir; charismatic authority resting on the personal magnetism of a leader; and legal-rational authority resting on rules and the office a person occupies, which is the basis of modern bureaucracy.
- Legitimacy is the general acceptance by the people that a government has the right to rule. A government may hold power without legitimacy, as military regimes that seize power by coup usually do until they win some measure of acceptance.
- Legitimacy is acquired through a free and fair election, through constitutional succession, through long and peaceful exercise of power, through performance that satisfies the people, and through recognition by other states and international bodies.
- Political socialisation is the lifelong process by which people acquire political values and attitudes, and its agents are the family, the school, religious bodies, peer groups, the mass media and political parties themselves.
- Political culture is the pattern of beliefs and attitudes a people holds towards its political system. Nigeria's is often described as a mixed or parochial-participant culture, with high voter mobilisation at elections sitting alongside weak day-to-day civic engagement.
- Other recurring concepts you must be able to define sharply: a nation-state, a society, a community, a constitution, democracy, the rule of law, the separation of powers, representative government, and accountability. The examiner often asks you to define two and distinguish them.
Key terms
- State
- A politically organised body of people occupying a definite territory, under a government, and possessing sovereignty.
- Nation
- A group of people united by common ancestry, language, culture, history or a shared sense of belonging, whether or not they have their own state.
- Sovereignty
- The supreme, final and unlimited authority of a state over all persons and associations within its territory and its independence from external control.
- Power
- The ability to make others act in a desired way, whether or not they consent to it.
- Authority
- The recognised right to exercise power and to be obeyed, derived from law, custom or office.
- Legitimacy
- The popular acceptance that a government has the rightful claim to govern and that its decisions ought to be obeyed.
- Political socialisation
- The process by which an individual acquires political beliefs, values and attitudes from the society around him.
Worked examples
Distinguish between a state and a nation, and explain why Nigeria is described as a state rather than a nation. (Essay question)
- Open with the two definitions, one sentence each, so the distinction is on the page before you argue anything.
- Set out the differences point by point in parallel: a state is a legal and political entity while a nation is a cultural and sentimental one; a state requires territory, population, government and sovereignty while a nation requires only a shared identity; a state can contain many nations while a nation can be spread across several states.
- Give examples on both sides: the Kurds are a nation without a state; the United Kingdom is a state containing the English, Scottish, Welsh and Irish nations.
- Apply to Nigeria: one sovereign territory with one central government, but more than two hundred and fifty ethnic groups, each with its own language, history and identity.
- Close with the consequence, that Nigeria's task since 1914 has been nation-building, the attempt to create a common loyalty over and above ethnic loyalty, through instruments such as the National Youth Service Corps, federal character and unity schools.
Answer: A state is a legal-political community defined by territory, population, government and sovereignty; a nation is a cultural community defined by common ancestry, language, history and sentiment. Nigeria qualifies fully as a state, since it has a defined territory, a permanent population, a government and sovereignty, but it is not a nation because its people do not share one ancestry, language or culture; it is instead a multi-national state in which nation-building remains unfinished.
Explain the difference between power and authority, and state three ways by which a government acquires legitimacy.
- Define power, then authority, and name the element that separates them: consent and the right to command.
- Illustrate with a concrete contrast, such as a policeman and an armed robber, both able to stop a motorist but only one entitled to.
- Add Weber's three types of authority to show the depth the examiner is looking for.
- List the ways legitimacy is acquired and explain each in a sentence rather than merely naming it.
Answer: Power is the ability to compel obedience by any means, including force, while authority is the recognised right to command and be obeyed, so authority is power that the governed accept as rightful. A government acquires legitimacy by winning a free and fair election, by coming to office through the procedures laid down in the constitution, and by performing well enough over time that the people accept its right to rule; recognition by other states and international organisations reinforces it.
The mistake to avoid
Candidates use state and nation as if they meant the same thing, then write an answer on Nigeria that contradicts itself halfway. They also use state in the Nigerian sense of Lagos State or Kano State in a question about sovereignty; those are federating units, not sovereign states, since they lack sovereignty and external independence.
In the exam
Open every definition question with a clean one-sentence definition before you expand, because the definition itself carries a mark. When asked to distinguish two concepts, do not write two separate paragraphs; set the differences side by side point against point, which is what the marking scheme rewards. Always finish with a Nigerian example, since the examiner wants application, not just theory.